| MULLARKEY | Toby, Crawley Town and 2023-24 Grimsby Town defender (9) |
| EFETE | Michee ___, Ross County and 2021-2024 Grimsby Town defender (5) |
| ISTED | Harry ....., Burton Albion, 2017- 23 Luton Town and 2023-24 Charlton Athletic goalkeeper (5) |
| MICHEE | Ross County and 2021-24 Grimsby defender (6,5) |
| CLIFTON | Harry ....... , Doncaster and 2015-24 Grimsby midfielder (7) |
| NEILWOODS | 1983-1986 Doncaster Rovers and 1990-1998 Grimsby Town striker (4,5) |
| CHRISTOPH | Birmingham and 2023-24 Darmstadt 98 defender (9,6) |
| CALAFIORI | Italy, Arsenal and 2023-24 Bologna defender (8,9) |
| HARBOTTLE | AFC Wimbledon and 2023-24 Hibs defender (5,9) |
| GUILHERME | West Ham and 2023-24 Palmeiras midfielder (4,9) |
| JORGENSEN | Chelsea and 2023-24 Villarreal keeper (5,9) |
| RYANGILES | Hull City and 2023-24 Luton defender (4,5) |
| KNOCKAERT | Anthony, 2016-20 Brighton, 2020-23 Fulham and 2023-24 Valenciennes winger (9) |
| GARYONEIL | 2022-23 Bournemouth and 2023-24 Wolves manager (4,5) |
| IDEHEN | Duncan _, 2020-2021 Grimsby Town and 2022-2024 Bristol City defender (6) |
| LEVER | Mark ___, 1988-2000 Grimsby Town and 2000-2002 Bristol City defender (5) |
| IMMINGHAM | Port on Humber estuary north-west of Grimsby (9) |
| MARCELCAS | 2001-03 Notts County and 2003-04 Grimsby midfielder (6.3) |
| COYNE | Danny ....., Tranmere Rovers, Grimsby Town, Burnley and Wales goalkeeper (5) |
| IVANO | Bonetti, Grimsby Town, Tranmere Rovers and Dundee midfielder (5) |
