| NAYIM | Real Zaragoza 1995 Cup Winners' Cup Final winning scorer (5) |
| YOUNG | Neil ___ , Manchester City 1969 FA Cup Final-winning scorer (5) |
| ASTLE | Jeff ___, West Brom 1968 FA Cup Final winning scorer (5) |
| WITHE | Peter ___, Aston Villa 1982 European Cup Final winning scorer (5) |
| DRAKE | Ted ___, Arsenal 1936 FA Cup Final-winning scorer (5) |
| GOTZE | Mario ___, Germany 2014 World Cup Final-winning scorer (5) |
| DAVIE | 1966-77 Aberdeen forward; 1976 Scottish League Cup Final winning scorer (5) |
| PIRES | Robert ..... , 1996-2004 France and 2000-06 Arsenal midfielder; 2003 FA Cup Final winning scorer against Southampton (5) |
| GREIG | John ..... , Rangers 1972 European Cup Winners' Cup Final-winning captain (5) |
| YORDI | Former Real Zaragoza striker; 2001-02 Blackburn loanee (5) |
| VILLA | Ricky ..... , Tottenham 1981 FA Cup Final replay winning scorer (5) |
| ALLANNIELSEN | Spurs 1999 League Cup Final winning scorer (5,7) |
| KANU | Nwankwo -, Nigeria 1996 Olympic football gold medal-winning forward; Portsmouth 2008 FA Cup Final winning scorer (4) |
| NIELSAN | Allan ....... , 1995-2002 Denmark, 1996-2000 Spurs and 2000-03 Watford midfielder; 1999 League Cup final-winning scorer (7) |
| EASTHAM | George ....... , Stoke 1972 League Cup Final winning scorer (7) |
| LAZARUS | Mark ....... , QPR 1967 League Cup Final-winning scorer (7) |
| ROBB | Davie .... , Aberdeen 1976 Scottish League Cup Final winning scorer (4) |
| IANSTJOHN | Scotland centre-forward; Liverpool 1965 FA Cup Final winning scorer (3,2,4) |
| TUEART | Dennis ?, 1974-78 Manchester City forward; 1976 League Cup Final winning scorer |
| TEMPLE | Derek ...... , 1957-67 Everton forward; 1966 FA Cup Final winning scorer (6) |
