| KEOWN | Martin ..... , 1989-93 Everton defender (5) |
| TILER | Carl ..... , former Nottingham Forest, Charlton Athletic and Everton defender (5) |
| LUCAS | France, Aston Villa and 2018-22 Everton defender (5) |
| DIGNE | France, Aston Villa and 2018-22 Everton defender (5) |
| JAMES | Everton defender; 2018 England debutant against Italy (5,9) |
| ROGER | 1967-79 Everton defender; 1977 League Cup Final replay own-goal scorer (5) |
| BALBO | Abel ..... , 1989-98 Argentina, 1989-93 Udinese and 1993-98 Roma striker; 1990, 1994 and 1998 World Cup participant (5) |
| STARR | Kenneth, US Solicitor General 1989-93 (5) |
| SHUTT | Carl ..... , 1989-93 Leeds United striker (5) |
| COYNE | Tommy ..... , 1992-97 Republic of Ireland and 1989-93 Celtic striker (5) |
| VANDENHAUWE | Pat _, 1985-1989 Wales and 1 984-1 989 Everton defender (3,3,5) |
| TARKOWSKI | Everton defender; 2018 England debutant against Italy (5,9) |
| DYLANKERR | 1989-93 Leeds and 1993-96 Reading defender (5,4) |
| JAGIELKA | Phil ___, England and Everton defender (8) |
| DISTIN | Sylvain ......, Manchester City, Portsmouth and Everton defender (6) |
| SYLVAIN | ....... Distin, Manchester City, Portsmouth and Everton defender (7) |
| MINA | Yerry .... , Colombia and Everton defender (4) |
| YOBO | Joseph ...., former Nigeria and Everton defender (4) |
| KENYON | Roger ...... , Everton defender 1967-78 (6) |
| XAVIER | Abel ...... , 1993-2002 Portugal and 1999-2002 Everton defender (6) |
