| DOYLEY | Lloyd ...... , 2013-14 Jamaica, 2001-15 Watford, 2016 Rotherham United and 2016-17 Colchester United defender (6) |
| HEATON | Tom ...... , Manchester United and 2016-17 England goalkeeper (6) |
| NYOM | Allan .... , Leganes, 2011-19 Cameroon, 2015-16 Watford, 2016-19 West Brom and 2019-22 Getafe defender (4) |
| KABOUL | Younes ...... , French defender who enjoyed two spells at Spurs; most recently at Watford, 2016-18 (6) |
| LAYUN | Miguel ..... , Club America, 2013-20 Mexico and 2014-15 Watford defender (5) |
| CHILVERS | Liam _, 2004-2006 Colchester United and 2013-2014 Port Vale defender (8) |
| KINSELLA | Mark ........, Colchester United, Charlton Athletic, Aston Villa and Republic of Ireland midfielder (8) |
| MYERS | Andy ..... , 1991-99 Chelsea, 1999-2003 Bradford City, 2003-04 Colchester United and 2004-05 Brentford defender (5) |
| SEARS | Freddie ..... , forward whose sides have included West Ham, Colchester United and Ipswich Town (5) |
| ROBIN | 1973-85 Ipswich Town and 1985-86 Colchester United forward (5,6) |
| TURNER | 1973-85 Ipswich Town and 1985-86 Colchester United forward (5,6) |
| KEEN | Kevin .... , 1983-93 West Ham United midfielder; 2015-16 Colchester United manager (4) |
| AGARD | Kieran ..... , Doncaster Rovers and former Everton and Rotherham United attacker (5) |
| SWAILES | Chris _, 1995-1997 Ipswich Town and 2001 -2005 Rotherham United defender (7) |
| BENTEKE | Christian ....... , Belgium, DC United and 2016-22 Crystal Palace striker (7) |
| GREENE | David ...... , 1996-2000 Colchester United defender; former Republic of Ireland U-21 captain (6) |
| CUBANHEELS | Grounded supporters don't allow scoundrels to follow Colchester United, initially (5,5) |
| GUZAN | Brad ..... , Atlanta United, 2006-21 United States, 2008-16 Aston Villa and 2016-17 Middlesbrough goalkeeper (5) |
| MCCAW | Richie ?, 2001-15 All Blacks flanker; 2006, 2009 and 2010 IRB International Player of the Year |
| CUETO | Mark ..... , 2001-15 Sale Sharks and 2004-11 England wing (5) |
