| LIDDLE | Gary ...... , 2006-12 and 2020-22 Hartlepool defender now with South Shields; Middlesbrough 2004 FA Youth Cup Final winner (6) |
| VLAAR | Ron ....., 2005-14 Netherlands defender at Feyenoord from 2006-12 and Aston Villa from 2012-15 between spells at AZ Alkmaar (5) |
| CARRAGEER | Jamie ......... , former Liverpool and England defender now TV pundit (9) |
| KEOWN | Martin ....., former England defender now a BBC football pundit (5) |
| BATES | Matthew ..... , Hartlepool defender whose former clubs include Middlesbrough and Bradford City (5) |
| LOUIS | 2015-17 Motherwell and 2017-18 Hartlepool defender (5,5) |
| LAING | 2015-17 Motherwell and 2017-18 Hartlepool defender (5,5) |
| NOBBS | Keith , 1985-1993 Hartlepool defender (5) |
| RYAN | Robbie .... , 1994-98 Huddersfield Town and 1998-2004 Millwall defender; 2004 FA Cup Final runner-up (4) |
| ARCA | Julio ___, 2000-2006 Sunderland, 2006-2013 Middlesbrough and 2015-2018 South Shields midfielder (4) |
| OSHEA | John ?, Republic of Ireland and Sunderland defender; Manchester United 2004 FA Cup Final winner |
| CURTIS | 2003-06 Millwall and 2008-12 Gillingham midfielder; 2004 FA Cup Final runner-up (6,6) |
| WESTON | 2003-06 Millwall and 2008-12 Gillingham midfielder; 2004 FA Cup Final runner-up (6,6) |
| ROBBIE | 1998-2004 Millwall defender, 2004 FA Cup final runner-up (6) |
| DEFOE | Jermain ....., 2004-17 England, 2017-20 AFC Bournemouth and 2020-22 Rangers striker (5) |
| VELA | Josh .... , Fleetwood, 2011-19 Bolton and 2020-22 Shrewsbury midfielder/defender (4) |
| LUSTIG | Mikael ...... , 2008-21 Sweden, 2012-19 Celtic and 2020-22 AIK defender (6) |
| BENHENEGHAN | Fleetwood, 2016-17 Motherwell and 2020-22 AFC Wimbledon defender (3,8) |
| SEANBURNS | 2011-18 Queen's Park and 2020-22 Stranraer defender (4,5) |
| BOTMAN | Newcastle and 2020-22 Lille defender (6) |
