| ASABA | Carl ....., 1998-2001 Gillingham, 2001-03 Sheffield United and 2003-05 Stoke striker (5) |
| CARLASABA | 1998-2001 Gillingham and 2001 -03 Sheffield United striker (4,5) |
| RAWLE | Mark ___, 2001-2003 Southend United and 2003-2005 Oxford United forward (5) |
| PETER | 2005-10 England and 2011-19 Stoke striker (5,6) |
| SCHEMMEL | Sebastien ........ , 2001-03 West Ham United and 2003-04 Portsmouth defender (8) |
| HOEFT | Carl ..... , 1998-2003 New Zealand prop whose clubs included Castres Olympique and Stade Toulousain (5) |
| CROUCH | 2005-10 England and 2011-19 Stoke striker (5,6) |
| IWELUMO | Chris ....... , 2008-10 Scotland and 2000-04 Stoke striker (7) |
| SOLTVEDT | Trond Egil ........ , 1997-98 Norway, 1997-99 Coventry, 1999-2001 Southampton and 2001-03 Sheffield Wednesday midfielder (8) |
| HILLS | John ..... , 1998-2003 Blackpool, 2003-05 Gillingham and 2005-07 Sheffield Wednesday defender (5) |
| VEART | Carl ..... , 1992-2000 Australia, 1994-96 Sheffield United and 1996-97 Crystal Palace striker (5) |
| DEANE | Brian ....., Sheffield United and Leeds United striker (5) |
| DANNY | 2003-05 Watford and 2005-09 Sheffield United forward (5,6) |
| TUDOR | John ___, Coventry City, Sheffield United and Newcastle United forward (5) |
| AGANA | Tony ..... , 1987-88 Watford, 1988-91 Sheffield United and 1991-97 Notts County striker (5) |
| STEVE | 2002-07 Sheffield United and 2007-09 Watford forward (5,5) |
| KABBA | 2002-07 Sheffield United and 2007-09 Watford forward (5,5) |
| TONGE | Michael ..., 2001-08 Sheffield United and 2013-15 Leeds midfielder (5) |
| EVANS | Ched ....., Sheffield United and Wales striker (5) |
| OLLIE | 2003-05 England, 2000-08 Leicester and 2010-12 Harlequins centre (5,5) |
